If your wife filed for divorce, you may be wondering whether she can also ask you to pay alimony.

Yes, she can. But filing for divorce first does not automatically entitle her to alimony.

New Jersey's alimony law is gender-neutral. A court can award alimony to either spouse, depending on the parties' financial circumstances and the facts of the marriage. The fact that your wife filed the divorce complaint does not, by itself, determine whether she receives alimony—or whether you will be required to pay it.

Instead, New Jersey courts look at factors such as each spouse's income and financial needs, the length of the marriage, earning capacity, marital lifestyle, parental responsibilities, and each spouse's financial and non-financial contributions to the marriage. N.J.S.A. 2A:34-23 specifically directs courts to consider these and other relevant factors when determining alimony.

Does Filing for Divorce First Affect Alimony in New Jersey?

Generally, no.

Being the spouse who files for divorce does not give your wife a special right to alimony, and being the spouse who receives the divorce complaint does not automatically make you responsible for paying it.

New Jersey Courts identifies the spouse who files the divorce complaint as the plaintiff and the other spouse as the defendant. That designation describes the parties' procedural roles in the lawsuit; it does not determine who is entitled to financial support.

For alimony purposes, the more important questions are financial and marital ones:

• Does one spouse have a genuine financial need?

• Does the other spouse have the ability to pay?

• What was the marital standard of living?

• How long were you married?

• What are each spouse's earning capacities?

• Did one spouse leave the workforce or sacrifice career opportunities?

• What parental responsibilities does each spouse have?

• What assets and income will each spouse have after the divorce?

In other words, who filed first is usually far less important than the financial circumstances of the marriage.

How Does a New Jersey Court Decide Whether to Award Alimony?

New Jersey's alimony statute lists 14 factors that courts must consider when determining an alimony award.

Those factors include:

1. The actual need of each party and the ability of the other party to pay.

2. The duration of the marriage.

3. The age and physical and emotional health of the parties.

4. The standard of living established during the marriage.

5. Each spouse's earning capacity, education, vocational skills, and employability.

6. How long the spouse seeking support has been out of the job market.

7. Each parent's responsibilities for the children.

8. The time and expense necessary for a spouse to obtain education or training to become self-supporting.

9. Each spouse's financial and non-financial contributions to the marriage.

10. The equitable distribution of marital property.

11. Income that may be generated by assets.

12. The tax consequences of an alimony award.

13. Any temporary support paid while the divorce is pending.

14. Other relevant circumstances.

The statute also requires the court to consider the relevant statutory factors in an alimony case and make specific findings regarding them.

Need and ability to pay are especially important

Suppose your wife earns $45,000 per year and you earn $150,000.

That income difference could be relevant to an alimony analysis—but it does not automatically mean she will receive a particular amount.

The court must look at the larger financial picture, including the parties' needs, available income, assets, earning capacities, and marital lifestyle.

The same principle works in reverse. If your wife earns substantially more than you, you may potentially have an alimony claim depending on the circumstances.

New Jersey law allows alimony to either spouse.

Does the Length of the Marriage Matter?

Yes.

The duration of the marriage is expressly listed as one of the statutory alimony factors.

The length of the marriage can also affect the potential duration of an alimony award.

For marriages or civil unions lasting fewer than 20 years, New Jersey law generally provides that the total duration of alimony should not exceed the length of the marriage, except in exceptional circumstances. The statute identifies several circumstances that may justify a different duration.

That does not mean a 10-year marriage automatically results in exactly five or ten years of alimony. The court must consider the circumstances of the particular case.

What If My Wife Works?

Having a job does not automatically prevent someone from receiving alimony.

At the same time, a spouse's income and earning capacity can be highly relevant to the analysis.

The court considers the earning capacities, education, vocational skills, and employability of both parties. It can also consider the length of time a spouse has been absent from the workforce.

For example, consider a marriage in which one spouse stayed home for many years to care for the children while the other spouse developed a career.

The stay-at-home spouse may have limited current income but substantial responsibilities and a lengthy absence from the job market. Those facts can be relevant when determining whether alimony is appropriate.

On the other hand, a spouse who is employed and has substantial earning capacity may have a different alimony claim.

The details matter.

What If My Wife Filed Because She Was Unhappy With the Marriage?

That generally does not mean she forfeits a potential alimony claim.

New Jersey's alimony statute focuses heavily on financial circumstances and the statutory factors rather than simply asking which spouse wanted the divorce.

For a typical no-fault divorce based on irreconcilable differences, the fact that one spouse decided to file does not by itself establish or eliminate an entitlement to alimony.

New Jersey Courts recognizes irreconcilable differences as a ground for divorce when the statutory requirements are met.

There can be exceptions involving certain misconduct and other circumstances, but those situations are fact-specific.

What About the Standard of Living During the Marriage?

The marital lifestyle can be an important part of an alimony analysis.

New Jersey law directs courts to consider the standard of living established during the marriage and the likelihood that each spouse can maintain a reasonably comparable standard of living after the divorce. The statute also states that neither party has a greater entitlement to the marital standard of living than the other.

New Jersey appellate decisions have likewise emphasized the importance of determining the marital standard of living when analyzing alimony.

This is one reason financial documentation matters.

If your wife is requesting alimony, you may need to examine not only her current expenses and income but also the financial picture you maintained together during the marriage.

Can My Wife Get Alimony While the Divorce Is Pending?

Potentially, yes.

New Jersey law permits courts to enter orders concerning alimony during a matrimonial action. Temporary support while a divorce is pending is often referred to as pendente lite support. The statute specifically identifies pendente lite support as one factor that may be considered in determining an eventual alimony award.

This is important because the financial arrangements during the divorce can look different from the final settlement or judgment.

If your wife has requested temporary support, do not assume that the amount requested automatically becomes the permanent alimony obligation.

The temporary and final stages involve different considerations and circumstances can change as the case progresses.

What Types of Alimony Are Available in New Jersey?

New Jersey law recognizes several forms of alimony.

Depending on the circumstances, a court may award:

• Open durational alimony

• Limited duration alimony

• Rehabilitative alimony

• Reimbursement alimony

The type and duration depend on the circumstances of the parties and the statutory factors.

For example, rehabilitative alimony can be designed to help a spouse obtain education or training necessary to become self-supporting. Reimbursement alimony can apply in circumstances where one spouse supported the other through an advanced education with the expectation of sharing in the resulting earning capacity.

Does Alimony Mean My Wife Gets Half of My Income?

No.

There is no simple New Jersey rule stating that a spouse who earns less automatically receives half of the other spouse's income.

Alimony is based on the facts and circumstances of the case. The court considers the statutory factors, including need, ability to pay, marital lifestyle, earning capacity, duration of the marriage, and other relevant circumstances.

That is why an accurate financial analysis is important before agreeing to an alimony amount.

What Should I Do If My Wife Filed for Divorce and Is Asking for Alimony?

Do not wait until the divorce is nearly over to understand your financial position.

Start by gathering documentation concerning:

• Recent pay stubs

• Tax returns

• Bank and investment accounts

• Retirement accounts

• Mortgage and other real estate records

• Credit card and loan statements

• Business interests

• Insurance

• Recurring household expenses

• Child-related expenses

• Other sources of income or assets

You should also understand what your wife is claiming.

Is she requesting temporary support? Permanent or open durational support? Limited duration alimony? Is she claiming that she cannot become self-supporting? Is there a significant income difference between you?

Those questions can materially affect the analysis.

Don't agree to an alimony number based on emotion

Divorce can make financial discussions intensely personal.

A spouse may say, "I can't afford to live without your income."

Another spouse may respond, "I shouldn't have to support her because she filed."

Neither statement answers the legal question.

The better approach is to examine the financial evidence, the marital lifestyle, the statutory factors, and the potential long-term consequences of any proposed agreement.

A settlement that looks manageable today can have significant consequences years later.

Can a New Jersey Alimony Award Ever Be Changed?

Sometimes.

New Jersey law contains provisions addressing modification or termination of alimony in certain circumstances, including retirement and cohabitation, among other situations. The specific rules depend on the existing order or agreement and the circumstances involved.

For example, the statute provides a rebuttable presumption that alimony will terminate when the paying spouse reaches full retirement age, subject to exceptions and the statutory requirements.

Alimony may also be suspended or terminated when the recipient cohabits with another person under the circumstances defined by the statute.

That is another reason to think beyond the initial monthly number when negotiating a divorce settlement.

What If My Wife Filed for Divorce but I Think I Should Receive Alimony?

It is possible.

New Jersey's statute does not limit alimony to wives or to the spouse who did not file for divorce. It permits an award to either party.

If you have substantially lower income or earning capacity, or if other circumstances support an alimony claim, you should discuss that possibility with your attorney rather than assuming 

Contact Us Today 

Have more questions regarding alimony in New Jersey? Contact Villani & DeLuca, P.C. today to speak with one of our experienced family law attorneys.